I recently saw the film "stranger than fiction" for the second time--okay, it's a yadda yadda hollywood film with will farrell--yeah it's fairly formulaic, he gets the girl in the end and all is happy faces....which is generally not like real life but hell, the illusion of happy endings is all that matters, no? and fuck you if you're too much of an arthouse snob to watch, because it's easily one of the BEST films of the last few years (along with little children, science of sleep and pans labrynth) Just watch.
What made this film so interesting to me was it's concept. To me, it was like eating a mental raw-food oatmeal vegan spirulina granola bar. after the film was over, i just sat and chewed and chewed and chewed, feeling new little tendrils growing in my brain...Like, i'd been having these thoughts for awhile now but up until then, they were only seeds. It took the film to bring them to sprouting. Ahhhh.... (Haven't felt so mentally....ERECT since i read the ishmael trilogy several years ago. ) love that feeling.
And when my seedprouts came to full bloom, i realized this: how much i actually hate the psychology industry.
Yes, i said Industry. Because that is what it is to me. Just another product to sell the people--this time the promise of fixing our mental problems all in a nice neat little package. How nicely it fits in with our goal-oriented lives. Get the job promotion, the trophy spouse, the killer abs, and fix all the errant dreadful neurotic thoughts that give us anxiety, so we can just be happy!!!!
As much of a motherfucker as freud was, most people can at least give him credit for opening folks up to the innerworkings of their minds. Which is all well and good. But modern psychology is such a recent invention, no? Like....maybe a few hundred years or so? am i right?
So what I want to know is-- what were people doing to ease their troubled minds BEFORE Dr. Phil, and Prozac and Cognitive behavioral therapy? I mean, were we all just a bunch of raving foaming loonies before our Beloved Psych Saviors were born?
The answer: they told stories. the stories of their lives, the stories of other people's lives, and the stories of their ancestors lives.
Stranger than fiction is about the healing power of stories.
Harold Crick, the main dude in this film, is hearing the voice of the narrator of his life. Eventually he is referred to--- not a Psychologist--- but a PROFESSOR OF LITERATURE (played beautifully by dustin hoffman--remnicent of his role in i heart huckabees-another outstanding "brainfood" film)
**SPOILER!!**
Through the professor, Harold begins to track down the narrator, and finds out she actually exists--he then, at last, obtains the manuscript of his life. He gives it to the professor to read first..... and the news of Harold's "ending" is grim.
"it can't be any other way," says the professor..... handing him the script. "i'm sorry harold but.... it's a beautiful ending."
One of the most moving scenes in the film (i cried like a baby watching it) is when Harold, after spending the entire night on the city bus reading the manuscript of his own life---resolves to accept the ending that was written for him, instead of fight against it.
In short, he chooses to live a poetic yet tragic life over a life of mere pain-avoidance and struggle. Fantastic!
Look, i think psychology is good for one thing: encouraging people to understand the story of their life and how it relates to others lives, and the story of the world in general. What i think it lacks is some sort of mythological framework, and it defaults to pathology and victimhood too quickly--psychology does not respect making the poetic choice---only the "healthy" one. And what the fuck is healthy? Who decided this? What are the criteria? the definition of HEALTHY changes as constantly as fashion trends and weather patterns.... If anything, each year seems to bring a new faddish disorder to the table and a thousand books are published about it. 300 years ago, did ADD really exist? Or is it just a convenient way of explaining away our reactions to speed culture and turning it into a personal problem rather than a societal one? How about Autism or Aspergers syndrome? Living more and more isolated has made us a bunch of social retards, hasn't it? No wonder there's so many people who have this disorder now. Very well, slap a new label on it, and try to sell some books and pills, keep the consumer cogs a truckin'.
Psychology was supposed to make us all deeper, but it failed. It gave us explanations, but no meanings. character analysis, but no narrative context to place it in......Yet millions of people flock to the therapists couch every day, hoping to achieve that dangling carrot called "mental health."
I say save your money, and go on a long walk through the city at night. You'd be surprised what you learn about your life at 3:00 am in the mission.
Besides, isn't it way more fun to consider your role in shaping the world and your own life if you see yourself as an active participant and character, rather than a passive analyst?
So be difficult. Be messy. Ask questions. Go deep and dark. Get morbid. Fall in love and get fucked up. Don't read the tabloid magazines to get your fill of the scandal you secretly crave-- MAKE SOME OF YOUR OWN.
And then write me and tell me what you've found, i wanna hear all about it.
your pal,
een.
Friday, August 31, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

1 comment:
My shrink says your WRONG.
Post a Comment